NFL commissioner Roger Goodell disclosed Tuesday at the league meetings that the NFL doesn’t have the required information or clarity to determine whether embattled Texans Pro Bowl quarterback Deshaun Watson should be placed on the commissioner-exempt list, the equivalent of paid leave.
That means that Watson, who has a standing trade request, a no-trade clause in his $156 million contract and is the high-profile subject of active trade discussions between the Texans and the Miami Dolphins and the Carolina Panthers, would be eligible to play immediately should he be traded by the NFL trade deadline next Tuesday afternoon.
Watson is facing 22 civil lawsuits alleging sexual assault or sexual misconduct. He is also facing 10 active criminal complaints filed with the Houston Police Department, eight from litigants, specifically massage therapists. Watson has not been charged with a crime and has denied wrongdoing through his attorney, Rusty Hardin. At one point, the FBI investigated, including whether Watson was the victim of an extortion attempt and whether interstate human trafficking laws had been potentially violated. A grand jury has been empaneled to investigate the matter.
Under its collective bargaining agreement's personal conduct policy, the NFL is not expected to punish Watson until his legal situation has been adjudicated.
“We don’t have all the access to that information and pride ourselves on not interfering with it,” Goodell told reporters in New York. “That process is ongoing There obviously are other, I’ll call it legal approaches that are being made either through civil cases. Obviously the police have been investigating also. We don’t have all the access to that information at this point in time, and we pride ourselves on not interfering in that, being cooperative as we can to make sure we get all the facts.
"But I think that process is still ongoing. Until that process is ongoing and we have enough data and enough information to be able to make a determination of whether he should go on commissioner exempt, we don’t feel that we have that necessary information at this point.”
None of the legal situations, including whether Watson will be indicted by a grand jury or charged directly by the HPD, is expected to be resolved by the trade deadline and the Harris County District Attorney’s Office is not obviously going to rush any decision based on football matters.
No trade is imminent at this time, according to sources.
Watson would waive his no-trade clause for the Dolphins, his preferred destination throughout this process since he first requested a trade in January due to the three-time Pro Bowl selection feeling disenchanted with the organization and chairman and CEO Cal McNair because of a lack of involvement and communication in the hiring process of general manager Nick Caserio and coach David Culley on the heels of him first being angered by the controversial trade of All-Pro wide receiver DeAndre Hopkins in March of 2020, according to league sources not authorized to speak publicly.
The Panthers have emerged as a player in the Watson situation and the quarterback, who played at nearby Clemson, respects the NFC South franchise and is open to potentially considering them as a destination should a trade be agreed to, according to sources.
However, Watson has been adamant throughout the process that the Dolphins are where he wants to go. Watson would not waive his no-trade clause for the Philadelphia Eagles, who were extremely interested in him and sent an investigator to Houston previously to investigate Watson’s legal situation, according to sources.
The Texans still want at least three first-round draft picks and a package of premium selections and/or high-quality players in exchange for Watson, according to sources.
The Panthers are disappointed in starting quarterback Sam Darnold, benching him during a fourth loss in a row Sunday to the New York Giants and replacing him with backup and former Houston Roughnecks standout quarterback P.J. Walker. Although coach Matt Rhule emphasized that Darnold will regain his starting job, the Panthers’ interest, especially owner David Tepper, is piqued by Watson, a multidimensional three-time Pro Bowl selection who led the NFL in passing yards last season.
The Panthers had previously moved on from pursuing Watson, partially due to acquiring Darnold in a trade from the New York Jets, and partially because of Watson’s unresolved legal situation.
Watson is “intentional” in his desire to never play another down for the Texans, per sources. Watson reported to training camp to avoid accruing $50,000 daily fines. He reports to work every day to work out, but has not practiced since training camp and he no longer attends meeting, per sources. He has been inactive every week for non-injury reasons-personal matter.
In an August news conference, Hardin stated about the FBI brief involvement in the case, which originated with plaintiffs’ attorney Tony Buzbee: "In April, the FBI came to us and told us they were investigating a matter as to whether one of Mr. Buzbee's clients had committed extortion in the way they were demanding money from Deshaun or what they would do if they didn't pay it," Hardin said.
One potentially bad scenario for Watson and any team that trades for him to consider: Watson possibly being charged with a crime and then being placed on the commissioner-exempt list and not going to trial until late next year and then being unavailable in 2021 and 2022 and, depending on how a possible case is adjudicated, potentially being punished for an undetermined portion of the 2023 season.
Watson is due a $35 million guaranteed base salary in 2022 and is being paid a $10.54 million base salary by the Texans this year.
Another wrinkle in the trade talks is the potential involvement of another franchise and another possible trade, not involving Watson, according to league sources.
Recently, McNair was noncommittal on the prospects of potentially trading Watson, who led the NFL in passing yards last season and is one of the most dynamic players in the NFL regardless of position.
"We'll just wait and see," McNair said during the Texans' second annual Founder's Day at the American Cancer Society Hope Lodge in Houston. "It's a day-to-day thing. Nick is in charge of that, so we'll see how that works out."
When asked to rate the odds of Watson being traded by a Nov. 2 league deadline, McNair smiled and replied: "I have no idea."
The Watson issue was inherited by Caserio and Culley.
"I think they've been put in a very tough spot, a spot that is not of their choosing and they've made the very best of it and sort of worked through it day to day," McNair said. "So, we'll see where it goes."
Watson reported to training camp to avoid incurring $50,000 daily fines.
The NFL issued a statement prior to training camp.
"The NFL’s review of the serious allegations against Deshaun Watson remains ongoing and active," the league said in an email. "We are working cooperatively with the Houston Police Department and ensuring that the NFL’s inquiry does not interfere with their investigation. As we continue to gather additional information and monitor law enforcement developments, we will make appropriate decisions consistent with the Collective Bargaining Agreement and the Personal Conduct Policy. At this time, there are no restrictions on Watson’s participation in club activities."
A source said that the NFL hasn't been given access to speak to many of the plaintiffs in the civil cases or third parties who may have relevant information. And the league hasn't been given access to evidence the police have gathered in their investigation.
Hardin, said during an August press conference that Watson has yet to speak to NFL investigators.
“The answer is no," Hardin said. "Here's the reason: The NFL regularly tries to not reach out to the defendant and his lawyers until the criminal investigation is over. They want to make sure they don’t interfere with the criminal investigation. Whenever the time is appropriate we will fully cooperate.”
Aaron Wilson has covered the NFL for 20 seasons, including the Texans, Baltimore Ravens, Tennessee Titans and Jacksonville Jaguars. He has previously written for The Houston Chronicle and The Baltimore Sun. He’s on Twitter: @AaronWilson_NFL and Instagram: @aaronwilson7128.